hope75
|
Posted 11:16 pm, 08/03/2012
|
He isn't yet, but he will be. And he really hasn't been surrounded by many GREAT players...that I can think of.
|
tirebiter999111
|
Posted 11:06 pm, 08/03/2012
|
downtowns right their dad was a great QB stuck on a losing team
|
colt45
|
Posted 10:31 pm, 08/03/2012
|
|
colt45
|
Posted 10:27 pm, 08/03/2012
|
bigdreams | Posted 3:53 pm, 08/03/2012 | Eli isn't that good he is fortunate enough to be surrounded by good players and he gets lucky. But we will see this season, they got rid of a few players. I just hope I don't get stuck with him as QB on my fantasy team! | Good enough to win two SUPER BOWLS
|
bigdreams
|
Posted 3:53 pm, 08/03/2012
|
Eli isn't that good he is fortunate enough to be surrounded by good players and he gets lucky. But we will see this season, they got rid of a few players. I just hope I don't get stuck with him as QB on my fantasy team!
|
downtown10
|
Posted 3:35 pm, 08/03/2012
|
Both Peyton and Eli will easily make the HOF, no question about it.
Their dad was a very good QB himself but he cam along before free agency and had to play a career with the lowly Saints plus he played during the run era.
He was a better athlete than either of his three sons.
|
kawninja09
|
Posted 3:16 pm, 08/03/2012
|
But you'd put this brother in who has only won 1 superbowl? thats what I can't figure out about all the conversations ppl have on this subject. Which they are BOTH better than their dad lol
|
tirebiter999111
|
Posted 3:08 pm, 08/03/2012
|
his stats say he's close
he just suffers from a severe lack of personality
nice guy... just hard to distinguish from wallpaper
|
MrKnowItAll
|
Posted 2:21 pm, 08/03/2012
|
He's not hall of fame material this soon in his young career, but I say he continues to play well enough over the next decade or so that he earns his hall of fame status quid pro quo. As a New Yorker, I am glad the Giants have a QB with Manning's talent.
|
scottieboy
|
Posted 2:03 pm, 08/03/2012
|
Eli will make it, hide & watch. Also, he is a manning
|
EWfan
|
Posted 11:04 am, 08/03/2012
|
Sorry chicken but Eli is probably in already and he's not even close to done yet
|
tdad
|
Posted 10:16 am, 08/03/2012
|
Close if not already. He is clutch and has won 2 Super Bowls. He has beaten the great Tom Brady head to head twice.
|
mustard-gas
|
Posted 9:23 am, 08/03/2012
|
I hate the NY Giants and Eli manning. However, I was watching Mike & Mike and a discussion came up about Eli being a hall of Fame QB." Do you football fans really think that Eli is HOF at this point in his young career? If os, or not, Why?
|
|
|